Strategies
and Programs that Improve Fluency
Reading fluency involves a combination of reading rate and accuracy.
Fluency involves reading smoothly and without hesitation and error.
A number of instructional strategies can improve reading. The work
of Curtis and Longo (1999) support three approaches: computer word
recognition activities and word games, collaborative oral reading,
and independent silent reading. The following strategies have also
been found to improve reading fluency.
Download handout in
mod1_9handout1.doc
or in mod1_9handout1.pdf
format.
| Fluency Strategies |
Description/Examples |
Reference |
| Computer word
recognition and word game programs |
Word Attack
(Davidson)
DLM Reading Fluency (SRA) |
Curtis &
Longo (1999)
Mastropieri & Scruggs (2000) |
| Many opportunities for successful
reading |
Create many successful reading
experiences |
Peregoy & Boyle (2001)
Pressly (2000) |
Listening to reading: oral
or silent preview reading |
Teacher read orally or students
pre-read passage |
Skinner, et al. (1997) |
| Repeated reading of the
same passage |
Up to 3-4 repeat readings
with teacher support |
Mastropieri & Scruggs
(1997) |
Learn high frequency words
|
Flash cards, games, etc. |
Peregoy & Boyle (2001) |
Curriculum-based measurement
used to monitor growth |
Graphic display of results
of growth |
Mastropieri & Scruggs
(2000) |
| Audio tapes of word lists
|
Taped lists of words with
student ability to respond |
Skinner, et al. (1997) |
Fuse Activities
for Decoding and Fluency
Mercer, et al. (2000) describe the successful use of fluency building
activities that include sound-symbol associations (phonics), recognition
of high frequency words, and repeated reading of stories. The strategy
that Mercer, et al. (2000) tested was authored by Campbell (1995)
and entitled the Great Leaps Reading Program. In one-to-one sessions
that lasted between 5 to 6 minutes a day each middle school participant
spent between 1-2 minutes working on phonics, sight phrases, oral
reading, and charting performance. Intervention groups lasted for
6-9 months, 10-18 months, or 19-24 months. Growth ranged between 2
to 3 years growth in grade level scores.
Reading Activities
Appropriate for Content Areas
It is possible for students to improve in reading and still to fail
in content areas. Some of the reasons for failure follow.
- Reading skill is still below the level needed in the content area.
- Poor transfer between reading instruction and content area reading.
- Lack of appropriate comprehension strategies to succeed in the
content area.
- Inability to report or demonstrate knowledge acquired in the content
area.
If content instruction is based on a single text and allows for little
in-class discussion poor readers will fail unless extraordinary accommodations
or assistance are in place. In content classes where there are multiple
texts, student discussion is encouraged, students learn practical
comprehension and memory strategies, and there are multiple avenues
for the demonstration of knowledge and skills most poor readers can
succeed. Unfortunately, studies show while secondary teachers support
reader-centered classes that strive for concept understanding, issues
of class control and required coverage result in classes that are
teacher-centered, fact loaded, fast paced, and low in discussion.
Running counter to teacher-centered practices is the movement toward
standards for student performance. The language of standards often
assumes high student involvement. The words used in standards often
expect that students can comprehend, interpret, evaluate, and apply
concepts and knowledge.
The following list provides those content class elements that are
commonly found and those that improve success for poor readers and
for most secondary level students.
Download handout in
mod1_9_handout2.doc
or in mod1_9_handout2.pdf
format.
| Static Class
|
Productive Class
|
| Single text |
Multiple texts and modes of data delivery |
| Fact dominated |
Concept dominated |
| Little pre-teaching of facts, concepts,
and vocabulary. |
Pre-teaching of facts, concepts, and
vocabulary. |
| Teacher control and order |
Learner-participant |
| Accountability testing |
Tests of growth toward standards |
|